Writings on History, Science, Reason, Classical Liberalism, the Alternative Future and the Philosophy of Life. Enjoy! Please feel free to comment.
Thursday, September 28, 2017
Western History 40: What was significant about the Punic Wars?
Tuesday, September 26, 2017
Personal Reflection VII- Recommended Books on Faith
Harold Kushner is always a hit with me - I read Who needs God about five months ago and recently completed Living a Life That Matters: Resolving the Conflict between Conscience and Success as a Theistic Both books provide a needed boost for the reader constantly struggling with an understanding of the working of G-d. The former makes a great case for using G-d as a lens to see the universe while the latter challenges us to think clearly about our notion of success in a world that often seems chaotic.Kushner's prose (which is live with real life examples) adds an added dimension to his analysis in 'Living a Life' by juxtaposing our individual struggle against the challenge faced by the patriarch Jacob in Bereshit (Genesis).
Ranking for Each: (A-)
Canadian David Adams Richards, a past winner of the Governor-General's Award did much to justify his reputation with a wonderful defense of theism in God Is. His first fifty pages where he deconstructs the mocking-of-god cultural meme, that has been for some time in vogue amongst the intelligensia, resonates as one of the best treatments of this topic that I have read for some time. Ranking: (A-)
Monday, September 25, 2017
Personal Reflection VI - My OCD
Once I was forced to leave in a hurry and my mom helped pack up the toys. Unfortunately she failed to return them all to their correct spot. I was haunted by the break in the natural that such recklessness conveyed. For hours afterward I ruminated on the consequence of such folly as I wondered with desperation on the severity of the misdeed.
This was one of many such actions that would linger in my mind especially if the circumstances prohibited (for some time) physical correction of the error. Such was the perilous equilibrium upon which the world’s fortune hung.
Later on my obsessions spread to cleanliness. Germs were everywhere and I loathed the notion that I a may be infected. Touching anything that appeared to be remotely unclean was a harbinger of disease and I constantly needed confirmation from my parents (more my mom than my dad) that I not fallen under the influence of some diabolical pox. I never did – clearly my immune system was tougher than I gave it credit for. However at the time this rarely mattered. For all intent of purpose I was the equivalent of a ‘Dead Boy walking’.
As I matured my fear of the unclean would be compounded by a need to wash and purify. I subjected my hands to endless episodes of vigorous of scrubbing that invariably caused them to chafe and redden. This was my remedy for coping with the infection that on its most diabolical level seemed so very real. Thankfully my mom could see through my actions and coaxed me to quit through a well-posed mixture of delicate reprimand and necessary empathy. My OCD would subside briefly, choked back but waiting behind the door to pounce should the next opportunity present itself.
In a sense OCD is a cunning beast in that it seeks the lowest level of your mental being and then strikes with brazen cruelty. Any doubt that it can latch onto becomes fair game. Once the intrusive thought worms its way into your head and escapes the initial check it stays there clawing at any contentment and magnifying its presence with the immediate passage of time. It can consume and it will for it is resilient.
The only respite, at least in those early days was rest, a clearing of the mind and a retreat to a cerebral space that it could not penetrate. There is an urgent need to re-focus, and I learnt how to do this, while eagerly waiting for the return of some facsimile of peace of mind that at the moment seemed extremely remote.
Western History 39: How did the Early Roman Republic expand?
Sunday, September 24, 2017
Personal Reflection V - Complexity
Western History 38: What were the defining features of the Roman Republic?
Western History 37: How did Rome emerge?
Monday, September 18, 2017
Personal Reflection IV - Losing interest in the Economist
Western History 36: What was the Hellenic Age?
Sunday, September 17, 2017
Personal Reflection III - Some Excellent Graphic Novels
Here are a few that I would recommend
1. Watchmen – Along with Frank Miller, Alan Moore is easily the best writer in the comic book world. Watchmen, is an in depth view into the psychology of being a superhero (a topic alluded to by Stan Lee and Miller as well). It is a truly spectacular work (far superior to V for Vendetta - another Moore work) and indicative of Moore’s real genius that I first acquainted myself with, during my teens, when he wrote the Future Shock Series for 2000 AD. Most people are familiar with the movie but the universe that Moore creates which brings us Ozymandias, the second Silk Spectre, Doctor Manhattan, the Comedian, the second Nite Owl and Rorschach is unparalled in its brilliance.
2. Contract with God – Will Eisner is another writer of immense distinction and his examination of Frimme Hersh in A Contract with God is a much needed work of philosophical significance. Eisner writes about tragedy, love and life struggle as seen through the eyes of a Jewish New Yorker trying to make sense of the never ending curveballs that the universe throws at him.
3. 300 – Frank Miller’s 300 is a gripping read from beginning to end. The story recreates, with significant artistic license, the events of the Battle of Thermopylae (480 BC). While it shouldn’t be taken as real history the excitement value of this story is incredible. Miller has a legacy of pushing the envelope with his writing and 300 is no exception. Fans of Miller should also read his crime thriller series, Sin City as well as his four-issue resurrection of Batman in the Dark Night Returns. The latter is a must for all-lovers of the caped crusader who is easily the most complex and dynamic of the DC characters.
4. The Stand – This Graphic adaptation of the Stephen King that carries the same name is not that easy to find but does exist in libraries in the GTA. Written by Roberto Aguirre-Sarcasa and illustrated by Mike Perkins (published in 2008) the Stand is divided into six books. It tells the story of the aftermath of a deadly plague that has wiped out most of humanity. The world is divided into camps of good and evil who battle for the spoils of what remains. The story arcs of its many characters (one of which is the demon Randall Flagg – a regular King villain) are filled with twists and turns that weld into a powerful plot devoid of oversig
Western History 35: Who was Alexander the Great?
Saturday, September 16, 2017
Personal Reflection II: An important Letter from the Future to the Past
Western History 34: What were the principle wars that plagued Classic Greece?
Western History 33: What were the Greek contributions to Drama and Sport?
Sunday, September 10, 2017
Personal Reflection I: Think for Yourself
While my tendency is to favour positions on the center-right of the political spectrum it certainly doesn't define my take on every issue (not by a long way). However I have noticed over the years that the moment one favours a particular left-right position on a single topic people naturally assume that you have to buy into the rest of the smorgasbord of ideas associated with that side of the political spectrum. This is ridiculous and incredibly short-sighted. While some people may order off a set menu of positions associated with a certain ideology I certainly don't and will continue to advocate for the most important of all notions ie. Think for Yourself.
Western History 32: How did Art develop in Ancient Greece?
Style Type
|
Style Example
|
Point of Note
|
Black-Figure Technique also Sister Red-Figure Technique
|
Pottery
techniques are seen on many amphoras and Bowls. Artists were often skilled
slaves. Various rich collections in museums across Europe (particular Munich
and Berlin).
|
Pottery Styles popular between the early 7th
century BC going forward to 530 BC.
|
Monumental Sculpture – Three Periods – Archaic, Classical
and Hellenistic.
|
Archaic c. 700-500 BCE
eg. Lady of Auxerre
Classical c. 500-300 BCE
Emphasis on Naturalistic Form. Eg. Venus Braschi by
Praxiteles
Hellenistic – c. 300 BCE-100 BCE. Blending of cultures.
More diverse portfolios eg.Winged Victory of Samothrace, Greco-Buddhist
frieze at Gandhara and the Venus De Milo.
|
Sculptures were made of a high quality limestone and were
carved using metal implements. Some were free standing. Others served as
reliefs. Bronze sculptures made use of the Lost wax technique.
|
Wall Painting + Panel Painting
|
Symposium Scene – Tomb of the
Diver at Paestum.
Pitsa Panels
|
Often used in Grave decorations as
well as resident and Temple Walls, Greek Wall Painting span a time scale
going from the Minoan Age to the onset of the Hellenic
|
Polychromy – Painting on
Stonework.
|
Trojan archers from the Temple of
Aphaia, Aegina.
|
Painting made use of bright colours
and were designed to enhance the visual appeal of the Architecture.
|
Coin Design
|
Macedonian tetradrachm with image
of Heracles.
|
Not seen by the Greeks as a major
art form but its presence is noteworthy. Extensive use of portraits. Many
techniques were borrowed from the Persians.
|
Architecture
|
Three defined order differentiated by Column Type
Doric (Earliest form) – Simple circular capitals at the
top of columns eg. Parthenon Triglyphs/Temple of the Delians.
Ionic – column capitals contain volutes (spirals)
eg. Erectheum.
Corinthian (Latest form)
- Ornate capitals. Impacted Renaissance Art.
eg. Arch at Ancona/Column at Phocas.
|
Tremendous tradition that spans
the period from 900 BCE to 100 CE.
Strong emphasis on Temples, open air theatres, monuments and council
buildings.
Many buildings in the US have
coped these Greek styles with respect to columns
eg. Western and Southern Life
Insurance Building in Cincinnati.
|
Friday, September 8, 2017
Western History 31: What scientists were influential in Ancient Greece?
Name of Scientist
|
Contribution
|
Archimedes of Syracuse
|
Determined the Law of the Lever
and the famed Archimedes Principle in Fluid Mechanics that carries his name.
Also contributed to hydraulics and optics.
|
Aristarchus of Samos
|
Presented what was probably one of the earliest
Heliocentric models of the universe.
|
Aristotle
|
Often believed to be the first scientist. Aristotle made
use of formal logic to understand the natural sciences. He also placed much
emphasis on perception and wrote opinions across a wide variety of scientific
disciplines. Although much of his work failed to withstand the rigours of
more focused experimentation his contribution to the various fields form an
integral part in the story of the emergence of science as a powerful
mechanism to understand the universe.
|
Ctesibius
|
Father of Pneumatics. Renowned for his work with
compressed air. Built a water clock.
|
Democritus
|
Together with his mentor Leucippus came up with the theory
of the indivisible atom.
|
Hero of Alexandria
|
Most likely built the first
steam-powered device.
|
Hippocrates
|
Father of Modern Medicine. Early
advocate of the systematic diagnostic
method.
|
Meton of Athens
|
Pioneer in astronomy. Developed
one of the earliest astronomical calendar calculators.
|
Ptolemy
|
Although superseded by the work of Nicholas Copernicus,
Johannes Kepler and Galileo Galilei – Ptolemy’s development of the Geocentric
model (as outlined in his work the Almagest) was the definitive astronomical
model for over a thousand years in the West.
|
Theophrastus
|
Developed one of the earliest classification systems in
Biology. He is considered the Father of Botany.
|
Thursday, September 7, 2017
Allied Leadership doubts on their eventual victory in World War Two
Did the Allied leadership, especially in England and America, ever actually doubt their eventual victory in World War Two?
I believe that there was a time from May 1940 (Fall of France) to June 1941 (Operation Barbarossa) where there was considerable doubt in Britain in particular as to whether they could hold out against the Reich.
During this period the US had not formally entered the war and the Soviets were actually supplying Germany with resources. The Italians went on the offense in the Mediterranean and Greece, Japan was having success in the East and morale was low in the UK following the very poor showing of the BEF forces in France and before that Norway.
British success at the Battle of Britain, the oratory of Churchill and better showings in North Africa, the Mediterranean and Abyssinia went someway to allay this fear. However these were very dark days
What is Classic Liberalism?
The philosophy emphasizes the necessary exchange of ideas, free speech, openness to debates, free markets, private ownership of property and the rule of law. Classic Liberals value a democracy or republic built on a foundation of scientific rationalism, empiricism and healthy skepticism. Individual rights sit at the cornerstone of classic liberalism.
Western History 30: Who were some of the great Ancient Greek Mathematicians?
Name of Mathematician
|
Key Contribution
|
Apollonius of Perga
|
Geometer – Famed for work on conic
sections – ellipse, parabola, hyperbola
|
Archimedes of Syracuse
|
One of the greatest minds of antiquity. Areas of
mathematical concern include – area of a circle, anticipation of calculus,
surface area and volume of a sphere, approximation of pi and the area under a
parabola.
|
Diophantus of Alexandria
|
Father of Algebra. Work centred on Algebraic Equations.
|
Eratosthenes
|
Besides inventing the discipline of geography he was the
first person to make use of Geometry to determine the circumference and
diameter of the Earth. Was also involved in developing a method to identify
prime numbers.
|
Euclid of Alexandria
|
Father of Geometry. Author of the Great work – The
Elements – which deduces the Principles of Geometry from several axiomatic
principles.
|
Hipparchus of Nicacea
|
Cofounder of Trigonometry. Discovered the Precession of
the Equinoxes, developed trigonometric tables and solved several problems in
spherical trigonometry.
|
Pythagoras of Samos
|
Although he is best known for his famous hypotenuse
squared formula (that every student at one time or another has been forced to
come to terms with) he did not derive this expression himself but merely
popularized its usage (the Babylonians beat him to the punch). Pythagoras did
however elucidate some of the mathematics that make the mathematics of music
harmonics possible.
|
Thales of Milletus
|
Besides being the Father of Western Philosophy, Thales was
a renowned Geometer who showed amongst other proofs that the diameter of a
circle subtends a triangle with a right angle at the circumference (arguably
the oldest proof in Geometry).
|
Western History 29: What was the contribution of the Athenian trio?
Western History 28: How did philosophy develop in Ancient Greece?
- Anaxgoras – Felt that material was ordered by the cosmic mind and that there was an infinite number of primary substances
- Anaximander – argued for an endless, unlimited mass not restricted by age
- Diogenes of Apollonia – Rationalized that air was the primary substance
- Empedocles – Favoured the four element makeup of matter – the four elements were water, earth, air and fire – Also spoke of forces within matter
Tuesday, September 5, 2017
Worldohistory Going Forward
Posts in Worldohistory will be of three types
a. General writing on various historically relevant topics (includes Quizzes)
b. The Western World in 300 Events (An Ongoing chronicle of key facets that shaped Western Civilization)
c. Reflections on topics not necessarily related to history - includes writing on Deism, Skepticism and Judaism.
The Western History 27: How did Democracy develop in Athens?
Sunday, September 3, 2017
Western History 26: What were some of the most important Greek City States?
For much of its history, Greek civilization was characterized by a collection of independent city-states, or poleis, rather than by a single unified political authority. These communities emerged and developed in the centuries following the Greek Dark Age (c. 1100–800 BCE) and eventually numbered in the hundreds. Each polis possessed its own political institutions, social structure, economy, religious traditions, and cultural identity. Geography also played a major role in shaping their character: some communities developed into maritime and commercial powers, while others relied more heavily on agriculture, territorial expansion, or military strength. The result was a remarkably diverse Greek world in which alliances, rivalries, wars, and cultural exchanges continually reshaped the balance of power.
Among the most important of these communities was Argos, a powerful city-state in the northeastern Peloponnese with roots extending back to the Mycenaean period. Argos was a longstanding rival of Sparta and competed with it for influence in the Peloponnese. Its relationship with the Persian Wars was more complicated than is sometimes suggested. Argos did not participate in the major Greek coalition against the Persians and remained officially neutral during much of the conflict. This position contributed to its diplomatic isolation among the victorious Greek states. In the fifth century BCE, Argos subsequently became an ally of Athens and participated in the struggle against Sparta, although its alliance with Athens was not always consistent or effective. Argos remained an important regional power but ultimately failed to challenge Spartan dominance of the Peloponnese.
Athens emerged as perhaps the most influential of the Greek city-states. Located in the region of Attica, Athens became renowned for the development of democracy as well as for its contributions to philosophy, literature, drama, art, architecture, and education. Its strategic access to the sea and the development of the port of Piraeus allowed Athens to become a formidable naval and commercial power. Following the Persian Wars, Athens became the leading member of the Delian League, which gradually developed into an Athenian maritime empire. Athenian power reached its height in the fifth century BCE before declining following its defeat by Sparta in the Peloponnesian War (431–404 BCE). Although Athens subsequently recovered much of its cultural and political importance, it never again exercised the same degree of dominance over the Greek world.
Corinth occupied an exceptionally strategic position on the Isthmus of Corinth, which connects mainland Greece with the Peloponnese. Its location and control of important land and maritime routes enabled Corinth to become one of the wealthiest and most commercially significant Greek poleis. Corinth initially opposed the growing power of Athens and fought against the Athenians during the First Peloponnesian War, including conflicts associated with Megara in the mid-fifth century BCE. It subsequently sided with Sparta during the Peloponnesian War but later became one of the principal opponents of Sparta during the Corinthian War (395–387 BCE), when it allied with Athens, Thebes, and Argos. Corinth later returned to the Spartan sphere of influence before becoming increasingly subject to Macedonian power. In 146 BCE, Corinth rebelled against Rome and was captured and destroyed by the Roman consul Lucius Mummius. The city was subsequently refounded as a Roman colony by Julius Caesar in 44 BCE.
Although Delphi was not a conventional polis in the same sense as Athens, Sparta, or Corinth, it was one of the most important religious centers of the Greek world. Located in central Greece, Delphi was home to the Temple of Apollo and the famous Pythia, the priestess through whom Apollo was believed to communicate prophetic messages. Greek tradition regarded Delphi as the omphalos, or symbolic center of the world. The sanctuary attracted visitors and offerings from across the Greek world and played an important role in religious and political affairs. Its influence extended well beyond the local community and contributed to the shared religious culture of the Greek world.
Miletus, one of the most important cities of Ionia in western Asia Minor, was a major center of trade, colonization, science, and intellectual activity. It is particularly associated with the emergence of early Greek philosophy through thinkers such as Thales, Anaximander, and Anaximenes, giving the city an important place in the history of Western philosophy. Miletus was also a significant maritime power and a prominent member of the Ionian League. In 499 BCE, it became the principal center of the Ionian Revolt against Persian rule, an uprising that helped precipitate the wider Greco-Persian Wars. The revolt was ultimately suppressed, and Miletus was severely punished by the Persians following its defeat at the Battle of Lade in 494 BCE. The city was later rebuilt and became particularly notable for its rational, grid-based urban planning, associated especially with the architect Hippodamus of Miletus. This approach to urban design subsequently influenced the planning of other Greek and Roman cities.
Mycenae, located in the northeastern Peloponnese, was one of the principal centers of the Mycenaean civilization, which flourished during the Late Bronze Age. The city gave its name to the civilization that dominated much of mainland Greece during the second millennium BCE. Mycenae declined as part of the broader collapse of the Bronze Age palace societies around the end of the thirteenth and during the twelfth centuries BCE. However, the claim that the city was specifically destroyed by the Dorians around 1100 BCE is uncertain and should not be presented as established historical fact. The site continued to be inhabited during later periods and retained religious and symbolic importance. Mycenae was also associated with the heroic traditions surrounding the Trojan War, although the historical basis of those traditions remains uncertain. By the classical period, however, Mycenae had become a much smaller community. In 468 BCE, it was captured and destroyed by Argos following a conflict between the two communities.
Olympia, like Delphi, was primarily a major religious sanctuary rather than a conventional city-state. Located in the region of Elis in the western Peloponnese, Olympia was dedicated principally to Zeus and became the site of the ancient Olympic Games. The first recorded Olympic Games traditionally date to 776 BCE, and the games continued to be held periodically for many centuries. They were eventually suppressed in the late fourth century CE, generally associated with the Christianization of the Roman Empire. Olympia was also home to the monumental Statue of Zeus, created by the sculptor Phidias. Constructed from gold and ivory, the statue was regarded in antiquity as one of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World. The sanctuary therefore served as both a major religious center and an important institution connecting the otherwise politically divided Greek communities.
Rhodes, an island in the southeastern Aegean and part of the Dodecanese, had a long history of settlement extending back into the Bronze Age. The island was inhabited by populations connected with the broader Aegean world and subsequently developed strong ties with Mycenaean and Greek civilization. Rhodes is mentioned in Homer's Iliad, while later Greek mythology associated the island with Helios, the sun god, and the nymph Rhodos. During the Persian Wars, Rhodes came under Persian influence, although political control of the island changed over time. In 408/407 BCE, the three principal Rhodian cities—Rhodes, Lindos, and Kamiros—were united through the establishment of the new city of Rhodes. The resulting state became a major commercial and naval power. During the Hellenistic period, Rhodes was particularly important in maritime trade, including the grain trade, and developed a reputation for naval strength and sophisticated maritime law. The famous Colossus of Rhodes, one of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World, was erected in the third century BCE.
Sikyon, also known as Sicyon, was a city-state located in the northern Peloponnese. It frequently operated within the Spartan sphere of influence but, like many Greek poleis, changed its political alignments according to circumstances. During the fourth century BCE, Sikyon came under Theban influence, particularly following the weakening of Spartan power after the Battle of Leuctra in 371 BCE. The city was renowned as an important center of Greek art, particularly sculpture and painting, and developed influential artistic traditions. Its political history included periods of tyranny, oligarchy, and democracy. Like many Greek city-states, Sikyon eventually came under Macedonian influence as Macedon rose to dominance over Greece.
Sparta, also known as Lacedaemon, was the dominant military power of the Peloponnese for much of the classical period and Athens's principal rival. Located in Laconia, Sparta developed a highly militarized social and political system centered on the training and discipline of its male citizens. Spartan forces played a crucial role in the Greco-Persian Wars, most famously at the Battle of Thermopylae in 480 BCE, where King Leonidas I and his contingent made a celebrated stand against the Persian army. Sparta subsequently defeated Athens in the Peloponnesian War, although the prolonged conflict placed considerable strain on the Spartan state. Spartan hegemony was short-lived. In 371 BCE, Thebes defeated Sparta at the Battle of Leuctra, decisively weakening Spartan power and ending its longstanding dominance over the Greek world. Sparta's political system, which included two hereditary kings, a council of elders, and an assembly, differed markedly from the democratic institutions that developed in Athens. Sparta also controlled substantial agricultural territory in Laconia and Messenia, with its economy heavily dependent on the labor of subject populations, particularly the helots.
Finally, Thebes, located in Boeotia in central Greece, became one of the most powerful Greek states during the fourth century BCE. Thebes was initially an ally of Sparta during the Peloponnesian War, although its relationship with Sparta became increasingly strained by Spartan attempts to maintain and expand their influence in Boeotia and elsewhere. Following the Peloponnesian War, Thebes emerged as a major opponent of Spartan hegemony. Its decisive victory over Sparta at the Battle of Leuctra in 371 BCE, achieved under the leadership of Epaminondas, transformed the balance of power in Greece. The dominance of Thebes was relatively brief, however. The city suffered a major setback following Epaminondas's death at the Battle of Mantinea in 362 BCE. In 335 BCE, Thebes rebelled against Macedonian authority following the accession of Alexander the Great. Alexander responded by capturing and destroying much of the city and enslaving many of its inhabitants. The destruction of Thebes marked the definitive end of its attempt to resist Macedonian supremacy and demonstrated the growing dominance of Macedon over the Greek city-states.
Taken together, these communities illustrate the diversity and complexity of ancient Greek civilization. They were not merely competing political units but also centers of distinctive military traditions, commercial networks, religious practices, intellectual movements, and artistic achievements. Their rivalries and alliances—particularly those involving Athens, Sparta, Corinth, Argos, and Thebes—shaped the political history of Greece and profoundly influenced the wider Mediterranean world.