Thursday, January 25, 2018

21 Realizations about Atheism and Atheists

These are based on my personal interactions with Atheists in the day-to-day and on various forums over the last ten years or so. Others may have had different experiences. Many of these points can apply to Deists as well. For the sake of simplicity I will not delve into the nature of Buddhism and Taoism as philosophies that are god independent.

1.       There is considerable variation among atheists in issues that are not God focused.

2.       Most atheists see God through the lens of the theistic society from which they have emerged. Although it sounds ridiculous there are clear distinctions between Jewish, Christian and Muslim Atheists.

3.       From personal observation Christian atheists focus on the divinity of Christ, Jewish atheists struggle with the notion of God and the Holocaust and Muslim atheists take issue with the excesses in the Quran.

4.       For most atheists opposition to the notion of God is generally directed at a theistic God. Many atheists are not even aware of the deistic God.

5.        A smaller sub-section of atheists are opposed to the entire notion of God itself. They see the concept as meaningless.

6.       Not all atheists take a militant position against theism. It is my experience that those who do often (but not always) come from a religious fundamentalist background.

7.       While the majority of atheists seem to have a positive attitude towards science this is not always the case. I have come across many atheists who have substituted a lack of belief in a God with some New Age Belief System.

8.       Most atheists tend to be left or center left with respect to the American political dynamic but there are a considerable amount of Right Leaning Libertarians who are atheists as well. I suspect opposition to existing institutions and norms may frame some of these positions.

9.       Many atheists (especially the philosophical types) seem to be intelligent but again this is not always the case. Some appear to be well read but this is after masked by selective mining of the relevant literature (theists can be just as guilty).

10.   Conservative Atheists do exist. Many take solace in Burke’s notion of the transcendent which they often see in the form of the Great Institutions of Western Civilization.

11.   Just like theists/deists there are good and bad people among atheists.

12.   Many philosophical atheists use a secular version of the Golden Rule to guide their moral decisions. Others have adopted philosophical positions from Kant, Mill, Rawls and Nozick.

13.   Many people have been driven towards atheism by the actions of Theistic Extremists eg. 911, and other types of religious inspired violence etc.

14.   Atheists tend to replace a belief in God with a belief in another type of transcendent. For those on the left it is usually humanism and/or a version of a political belief system that is largely collectivist. Libertarian atheists often opt for the Individual and the notion of liberty.

15.   Individuals growing up in countries with a strong atheist population (Sweden, Norway, Estonia etc) have more of a complacency about their atheism than those living in countries with a stronger theistic base such as the US or the nations of the Middle east.

16.   Many atheistic arguments derive from the writings of David Hume and Bertrand Russell. Richard Dawkins in particular relies heavily on Russell.

17.   When push comes to shove most Atheists are Agnostic as opposed to Gnostic with respect to their position on God. They do however vary with degree.

18.   It is a waste of time debating with hardcore atheists. Scientific debates always come down to the nature of evidence and the notion of material reductionism. There is virtually no impasse beyond this.

19.   When faced with a weak theist opponent Atheist debaters will often resort to mockery. Many theists set themselves up for this.

20.   Atheists belonging to the Anti-Theist sub-grouping all too often use a literal reading of the Theistic Texts in an argument. Against weaker theistic opponents this is effective but when up against tougher opposition (check out Harris v Prager) it can backfire.

21.   Some atheists actually see religion as necessary for the masses but not for themselves per se. Not every atheist believes in throwing the shared religious heritage out the door.


No comments: